Warren in the Case Against Abortion
Don Marquis, author of Why Abortion is Immoral, argues against abortion and speaks to the reader in terms of the basic feature of why killing is wrong which applies to a fetus based on personhood.
Pro-choice groups are for abortion, or the choice of the mother.
Let us call the view that abortion is impermissible even to save the mother's life "the extreme view." I want to suggest first that it does not issue from the argument I mentioned earlier without the addition of some fairly powerful premises. Suppose a woman has become pregnant, and now learns that she has a cardiac condition such that she will die if she carries the baby to term. What may be done for her? The fetus, being to life, but as the mother is a person too, so has she a right to life. Presumably they have an equal right to life. How is it supposed to come out that an abortion may not be performed? If mother and child have an equal right to life, shouldn't we perhaps flip a coin? Or should we add to the mother's right to life her right to decide what happens in and to her body, which everybody seems to be ready to grant--the sum of her rights now outweighing the fetus's right to life?
But it might be argued thatthere are other ways one can have acquired a right to the use of anotherperson's body than by having been invited to use it by that person. Suppose awoman voluntarily indulges in intercourse, knowing of the chance it will issuein pregnancy, and then she does become pregnant; is she not in part responsiblefor the presence, in fact the very existence, of the unborn person inside? Nodoubt she did not invite it in. But doesn't her partial responsibility for itsbeing there itself give it a right to the use of her body? If so, then heraborting it would be more like the boys taking away the chocolates, and lesslike your unplugging yourself from the violinist--doing so would be deprivingit of what it does have a right to, and thus would be doing it an injustice.
Therefore, the proof of abortion being unethical lacks....
The difficulty I point tohere is not peculiar to the right of life. It reappears in connection with allthe other natural rights, and it is something which an adequate account ofrights must deal with. For present purposes it is enough just to draw attentionto it. But I would stress that I am not arguing that people do not have a rightto life--quite to the contrary, it seems to me that the primary control we mustplace on the acceptability of an account of rights is that it should turn outin that account to be a truth that all persons have a right to life. I amarguing only that having a right to life does not guarantee having either aright to be given the use of or a right to be allowed continued use of anotherperson s body--even if one needs it for life itself. So the right to life willnot serve the opponents of abortion in the very simple and clear way in whichthey seem to have thought it would.
Persuasive Essay on Abortion | We've moved
The first thing to be saidabout this is that it is something new. Opponents of abortion have been soconcerned to make out the independence of the fetus, in order to establish thatit has a right to life, just as its mother does, that they have tended tooverlook the possible support they might gain from making out that the fetus isdependent on the mother, in order to establish that she has a special kind ofresponsibility for it, a responsibility that gives it rights against her whichare not possessed by any independent person--such as an ailing violinist who isa stranger to her.
Argumentative Essay Against Abortion Free Essays
By having an abortion she would not have to deal with all of the issues like these, though she would have to deal with the emotional aspect of deciding to terminate the fetus which would be a decision that should be left to that person, not a law....
Argumentative Essay on Abortion - 449 Words - StudyMode
Some people think that abortion is a good idea to solve problems and that it is justified yet the Catholic Church would argue this is not the case and that abortion is wrong.